"In the case of V.T. and Others v. Azerbaijan, the ECtHR judgment is FINAL"
  • November 15, 2026

"In the case of V.T. and Others v. Azerbaijan, the ECtHR judgment is FINAL"

The ECtHR Judgment Establishing Azerbaijan’s Responsibility for the Torture and Murder of an Armenian Serviceman Has Become Final․

The team of lawyers who handled the case has issued the following statement:

“The European Court of Human Rights judgment establishing Azerbaijan’s responsibility for the torture and murder of an Armenian serviceman has become final: Azerbaijan’s diplomatic protests and attempt to refer the case to the Grand Chamber have been unsuccessful.

In our assessment, this outcome constitutes an important legal basis for the protection of persons affected by armed conflicts and their families.

On 2 November 2026, a panel of five judges of the Grand Chamber rejected the application by the Government of Azerbaijan to refer the case of V. T. and Others v. Azerbaijan to the Grand Chamber. Thus, the Court’s judgment of 18 June 2026 has become final and enforceable. The applicants are the serviceman’s parents and sister, who applied to the ECtHR on 13 April 2016. Their interests were represented by a legal team, namely Ara Ghazaryan, Haykuhi Harutyunyan, Araks Melkonyan, Artak Zeynalyan, Hasmik Harutyunyan and Siranush Sahakyan.

The torture and murder of a wounded and defenceless serviceman cannot be justified by war. The Court established Azerbaijan’s responsibility and also recognised the violation of the family members’ own rights. Azerbaijan’s denials and its complaint to the Grand Chamber have not changed this outcome.

During the April 2016 war, Major H. T.’s military vehicle came under attack by an Azerbaijani sabotage group near Talish. He was wounded and was no longer able to move or defend himself independently. The Court established that, in this condition, Azerbaijani servicemen tortured and killed him by beheading. Violations of the right to life guaranteed by Article 2 of the Convention and the prohibition of torture set out in Article 3 were found.

The Court also separately assessed the suffering of the family. The brutal murder of their relative, the mutilation of his body, and the impossibility of recovering the missing parts of his body and arranging a proper burial had caused severe and prolonged mental suffering for his parents and sister. In these circumstances, the Court also recognised a violation of their rights on account of the degrading treatment prohibited by Article 3 of the Convention.

Azerbaijan attempted to deny the involvement of its servicemen and exclude its responsibility by invoking its lack of control over the territory. The Court established that the serviceman had been under the actual authority and control of Azerbaijani forces. Azerbaijan’s version of events was also contradicted by statements made by Azerbaijani officials themselves and by videos that had been published. The objection that the family should first have applied to the Azerbaijani authorities was also rejected: the Court took into account the practical and systemic obstacles facing the Armenian applicants and found that Azerbaijan does not provide any effective remedy for ethnic Armenians.

Following the publication of the judgment, Azerbaijan had also expressed its dissatisfaction at the diplomatic level. On 22 June 2026, the Head of the Council of Europe Office in Baku was summoned to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Azerbaijan. The Azerbaijani side described the judgment as unfair and biased, objecting, in particular, to the use of the name “Nagorno-Karabakh Republic” and the wording referring to its bodies. Azerbaijan’s dissatisfaction and its attempt to refer the case to the Grand Chamber have not changed the final legal and just outcome of the case.

The execution of the final judgment will be supervised by the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe.

We would also like to inform you that our legal team has submitted applications to the ECtHR concerning other war crimes committed during the four-day war of 2016, in respect of which we expect new judicial decisions.”